Ep 407: Transphobia and Reproduction
Transcript Info:
SARAH: Hey, what's up? Hello! Welcome to Sounds Fake But Okay, a podcast where an aro-ace girl (I'm Sarah, that's me.)
KAYLA: And a bi-demisexual girl (that's me, Kayla.)
SARAH: Talk about all things to do with love, relationships, sexuality, and pretty much anything else we just don't understand.
KAYLA: On today's episode: Transphobia and Reproduction.
BOTH: Sounds fake, but okay
SARAH: Welcome back to the pod for the second time because we got two and a half minutes into recording and Kayla realized she never hit record.
KAYLA: Which I will say, I don't think I've ever done that in hundreds of episodes. Like, we've lost recordings, we've had recordings like stop in the middle for like glitches, stuff like that. I don't remember a time where I've ever just not… simply not clicked the button and just started talking.
SARAH: She just said none of that.
KAYLA: I don't know why, because I have… on my computer, I have you on half of it, like the Zoom on half and the GarageBand on the other half because I'm always afraid it'll stop when I'm not looking.
SARAH: Mm-hmm
KAYLA: So, it was there, not moving…
SARAH: Just not moving
KAYLA: And I just didn't really consider that.
SARAH: I love that for us.
KAYLA: So anyway
SARAH: Well, what we determined is that we don't have a housekeeping, but we will next week.
KAYLA: Right, yeah. So, don't you worry about that.
SARAH: A little fun surprise. Kayla, what are we talking about this week?
KAYLA: This week, it's more bad people with bad opinions saying stupid things on the internet and us talking about it even though we probably all agree all of us listening here anyway. What's the point? I don’t know
SARAH: Precisely. This one once again comes to us from bullshit Twitter. But it's less discourse and more a video that people had takes upon, but like not discourse-y takes, just like, yeah, we all agree.
KAYLA: We all agree this is stupid.
SARAH: Well, I didn't really look too much in the comments, but I…
KAYLA: We can hope and let's just assume that everyone agreed with us and they're good people.
SARAH: Yeah. So, this is a video, it appears to be one of those videos where like a generic conservative white boy in a suit goes to a college campus and sets up a table and is like, ‘Debate me!’
KAYLA: Yeah. A really chill guy.
SARAH: Yeah, super-chill. There's cameras, there's mics, but it's like… it's not like a big setup, it's just like a gorilla debating.
KAYLA: Sure.
SARAH: I do not recognize this generic white man, I don't know how relevant he is. In any case, here he is talking to a...
KAYLA: Do we know what campus he's on?
SARAH: No, I have no idea.
KAYLA: Okay.
SARAH: I don't even know who he… like, I don't have the name of his account either.
KAYLA: Great. Good.
SARAH: But… so, there's… a person who came up to the mic is this trans woman and she goes up and she's like, hey, I look female, I have a vagina…
KAYLA: Okay.
SARAH: Am I not a woman? And he goes, do you have ovaries? And she says, no. And so, he says, so you don't have sex organs at all anymore? And she was like, no. And he goes, so at this point you're nothing.
KAYLA: Oh, right.
SARAH: And she's like, no
KAYLA: Wrong.
SARAH: And he's like, don't you think you've made mistakes, like having done this to your body? And she's like, no
KAYLA: No, good.
SARAH: And then he says… she's like, so, you think that like body dysmorphia that leads one to make these changes that I'm very happy with is mental illness. And he's like, yeah, because the point of biological life is to reproduce and you have no sex organs and you can't reproduce.
KAYLA: Okay.
SARAH: So that's the video.
KAYLA: Great.
SARAH: The quote retweet I saw says, it is from @redspecter4, not verified, so I will give you their @.
KAYLA: So real.
SARAH: And it says, trans women who medically transition are such an affront to the fascist mind precisely because we are useless. And worse than that have betrayed manhood in the name of being women. We truly love womanhood in a way a fascist despises. And I saw this and I said, that is a really interesting conversation to be had about trans women, trans people, anyone who gets any sort of sex-change surgery, any sort of gender-affirming surgery that makes them unable to produce, whether they're taking hormones that make you, during the time you're taking them, unable to reproduce in the manner that this straight white man thinks you should. That these people, because they cannot reproduce traditionally…
KAYLA: Are nothing.
SARAH: That's an argument against trans people, but they become useless.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And that the main point of life is to reproduce because we're having a birth rate crisis, whatever.
KAYLA: Actually, I just don't think that's true…
SARAH: Here's the thing about that.
KAYLA: I feel as though we're having an overpopulation crisis.
SARAH: We do have an overpopulation crisis. There are a couple of things about this. One, the overpopulation crisis is most potent in developing countries.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And so, people in Western countries don't fucking care about them.
KAYLA: Yeah, it's not like it's an evenly dispersed issue across the globe.
SARAH: Right. Like some places like Japan are like actually having a birth rate crisis, that no one is having kids. But then you go to somewhere like Nigeria and like the birth rate is very high.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: There's that. There's also the fact that we are overpopulating the earth. Like point blank, it's true. We don't know how much more it can handle.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: But they only care about the economic impacts.
KAYLA: Yeah. I mean, we built… the structure of our country was built to work around a certain number of people, and if you lose people, it starts to not work.
SARAH: And a growing number of people, because how else are we going to pay out social security checks?
KAYLA: True. It makes me think about like when everyone worked from home during COVID and then no one wanted to go back and they were like, well, we have all this infrastructure built around people going into offices. It's basically that issue just on a larger scale of like, well, we built all these buildings and we made all these jobs and we did all this stuff to have this amount of people living here and now there's less. And so now what do I do?
SARAH: Yeah. We promised the baby boomers that we would pay them social security when they're old and you better fucking pay them their fucking social security. But when we're old, will we have social security? I don't know.
KAYLA: No, probably not.
SARAH: So, basically, it's… they built a system upon like exponential growth that's just not realistic.
KAYLA: Which is just not sustainable or good.
SARAH: So often when they're talking about the population, like the birth rate problems, it's really about economics and capitalism.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: Also, I think for many of them, it is about maintaining a certain ‘purity’ of race.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Because the races, they're mixing.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And we don't want inferior babies being born; we need more white, blonde hair, blue-eyed babies being born. And so that's a concern of theirs, however unfounded and however fucking racist.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: So, it's a very fascist… it goes hand in hand with fascism. And I found an article from The Intercept called, it’s from 2022, called ‘The Right's Creeping Pro-Natalist Rhetoric on Abortion and Trans Health Care.’ Now, this article was not as directly relevant to this podcast as I hoped it would be. However…
KAYLA: However
SARAH: It gave a lot of very interesting information. The bulk of this article really is talking about abortion.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And Samuel Alito, Supreme Court Justice of the United States of America said, it is beyond dispute that Roe, aka Roe versus Wade, the Supreme Court ruling in the 70s that made abortion legal in the United States, is beyond dispute that Roe has had that demographic effect. A highly disproportionate percentage of aborted fetuses are black. And then Alito cited Justice Clarence Thomas, who warned in 2019 that abortion could become a tool of eugenic manipulation. So, they're anti-abortion because they're like, if we allow abortion, they'll do eugenics. And it's like, that’s… people who really want to do eugenics will do it regardless.
[00:10:00]
KAYLA: Well, it's also like that just… and it says this in the article, that just simply makes no sense, because the right to have an abortion is a personal decision to not have the baby, not like the government telling you, hey, you non-white person, you should abort your baby so we have less non-white. Like, that's just not… like they're just trying to like fear-monger and get people on their side.
SARAH: And if it is true that more black babies are aborted than white babies…
KAYLA: That points to completely other issues.
SARAH: Exactly. Like… let's assume it's true, I have no idea if it's true, let's assume it is. This does not point to a behavioral issue on behalf of white or on behalf of black women.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: This points to a systemic economic issue where black women don't have access to the same types of contraceptives and like family planning… just like the sort of shit that like so many rich or even just like middle class white women have access to, it is because of redlining and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, black women are less likely to have access to.
KAYLA: Yes.
SARAH: So, it's an entirely different fucking thing.
KAYLA: Well, also, black women are just also more likely to not have like the money and resources that a white woman would have to be like, okay, I have an unplanned pregnancy. Like, I didn't want this, but I have enough money and resources to be able to handle it. And so, I'll choose not to abort it versus someone who is like, I don't have the economic resources to do this so I don't really have a choice.
SARAH: Yeah. Now, then they go on to kind of connect that to gender-affirming care for trans youth, basically saying most of it is not sterilizing.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Puberty delaying medication has been safely used for decades.
KAYLA: Mm-hmm
SARAH: And so, the argument that these people then make like, oh, you're like sterilizing children, you're mutilating children, whatever, just doesn't really bear fruit.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: But they're so worried about sterilizing children. Why are you looking at like a 12-year-old and thinking about their future capacity to reproduce?
KAYLA: Well, because there’s also a line in this article about that, that I found very bizarre, that was… so in a… just a quote from this article, in a February legal opinion, Texas attorney general Ken Paxton argued…
SARAH: Boooo!
KAYLA: That gender-affirming procedures met the state's criteria for child abuse, mentioning children's fundamental or constitutional, ‘right’ to procreate more than a dozen times.
SARAH: Children's right to procreate?!
KAYLA: What are you saying?! What are you saying?! What is that?! What is that?!
SARAH: I think the Right thinks about children having sex so much more often than literally anyone else. And so, when you do something that might tangentially have an impact on 1% of minors who might choose to have sex, they're like, you did it because of that. And it's like, no, you're the only one who is thinking about that all the time.
KAYLA: Like, why am I looking at a 10-year-old and being like, they must have the right to procreate?
SARAH: Yeah. Hello?!
KAYLA: Like, what?! Like, they should have the right to do with their body what they want. And if that's the right to procreate, great. But like, I just think they should have the right to their body.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Like, what are you…
SARAH: And with kids… with minors who are getting gender-affirming care, it's not like they just decided one day, like, hey, cut my boobs off, you know? Like, as an adult, you have to go through a lot to get gender-affirming care. As a child, it's even harder.
KAYLA: That's what like… because from my understanding, gender-affirming surgeries don't typically… like, that doesn't happen for minors, typically
SARAH: No
KAYLA: Because it's like, your body is still growing, so it doesn't make sense physically to do that kind of surgery on a growing body.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: So, it's like, the hormones make sense, like puberty blockers that completely make sense, because that's also something that's much more reversible if you're worried about like, oh, this kid could change their mind, because their brain hasn't finished cooking.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: But like, it's not like the super-intense surgeries are happening on a minor.
SARAH: Yeah. This says, guidelines from leading medical organizations generally do not recommend genital reconstruction surgery before the age of 18.
KAYLA: Yeah, which makes sense, because you're still growing and your like hormones are doing whatever.
SARAH: Yeah. As for hormone treatments, Dr. Joshua Safer, executive director of the Mount Sinai Center for Transgender Medicine and Surgery, told The Intercept that fertility can usually be regained once the hormone regimen is ceased for a length of time. I have seen recently on social media a couple, I believe they might be both trans men? In any event, one of them is a trans man and is currently pregnant. And they chose to do that because they wanted to have a child that way.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: But for a trans man to be pregnant, there's definitely going to be plenty of body dysmorphia and plenty of stuff involved in that.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: But despite him being a trans man and having had gender-affirming care, I don't know to what extent, he can still have a fucking kid.
KAYLA: He was able to get pregnant, yeah
SARAH: It's like how… what's it called when they make a man so that his sperms can't go wheeee?
KAYLA: Vasectomy?
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Yes
SARAH: Like, vasectomies are reversible.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: So is almost all of this.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: So, let's bear that in mind. Then the article talks about eugenics and fascism in the… what's the word I'm looking for? In relation to Nazi-Germany and how it was represented there. Abortion and contraception were banned, traditional gender rules were reimposed, and economic benefits were awarded to women who focused on homemaking.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: These policies were explicitly tied, I'm quoting, to the belief in the superiority of the Aryan race, promoting the expansion of the white population went hand in hand with the compulsory sterilization and genocide of those deemed racially inferior. So, I think… I mean this is related to what I was talking about earlier about like, they don't want super right-wing, like, white nationalists, like, deeply, deeply racist people, only want the people that they want to reproduce, not other people.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: And so then thinking back to this man who's like, ‘Debate me!’ It makes sense in like a twisted, horrible way that if someone is, let's call it sterile in this context, that they are nothing and they are lesser because in his mind, the only people that are sterile are the ones who shouldn't be reproducing. And so, he looks at this woman and is like, why would you do that to yourself?
KAYLA: Hmm, I see.
SARAH: And it's like, she wasn't fucking thinking about that because that wasn't what was important to her.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Just because it's important to you, it doesn't mean it's important to everyone. And then this article, for someone who said this article wasn't that helpful to this podcast, we're really hitting it, I don't know.
KAYLA: We're really hitting it.
SARAH: It talks about like Great Replacement Theory, like the white supremacist belief that like, they're going to replace us.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Fox News host Heather Carlson has stoked panic about America's fertility crisis and declining sperm counts.
KAYLA: It's almost as if you were really worried about lower birthrates and fertility crises and people like needing more… because like, I do feel like there is more infertility now than there used to be. I mean, maybe it's just that people talk about it more openly now.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: But it just feels like people are having a much harder time getting pregnant.
SARAH: Microplastics.
KAYLA: Yeah. And like maybe…
SARAH: It has got to be the microplastics.
KAYLA: No, but like legit, it's like, I would be very interested to know in the US versus like somewhere like Europe that is like similar in like a lot of ways, but not similar in like regulations, but like food and stuff like that. It's like, huh? What if we, I don't know, gave people healthcare and they had more money and like, it's just…
SARAH: More people would choose to have fucking kids.
KAYLA: It's just like, if you're truly worried about people not having kids, why are you not making it easier to have and afford kids?
SARAH: No, they just want you to have kids by force, they just want you to have them at gunpoint.
KAYLA: Like it just doesn't…
SARAH: And then they'll be poor and then they'll get treated like shit. And they'll be like, well, you shouldn't have had kids then if you couldn't pay for them. You literally forced them to.
KAYLA: Is it that they want more poor kids and so that they have to do the jobs that like the rich people don't want to do? Is that what we're hoping for?
SARAH: I don't know.
KAYLA: Not that a poor person can't be smart and get a rich person’s job, that's not what I mean.
SARAH: But they wouldn't think that. They would be like, no, it's like a fucking Caste system. You know?
KAYLA: Yeah. Like, yeah, are they just hoping to… yeah.
SARAH: Okay, that's the gist of that article. I… look, can we talk about him referring to people without sex organs as nothing? Let's dive into that.
[00:20:00]
KAYLA: Yeah, I mean, it's so… I mean, I also want to get back to like the point of biological life is to reproduce.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Because like… and I'm not a scientist. But like, I can see a world where there's an argument for like unevolved base-level animals, like, yeah, they need to reproduce to keep their species alive. That's like, duh.
SARAH: Instinct.
KAYLA: But even when you look at animals, there are so many animals that have like gay tendencies that it's like extremely natural in their environment to have like…
SARAH: What do they got gay penguins for? Huh?
KAYLA: Yeah, like gay penguins or like more than two… like, more than just like the mother and father taking care of like children. Like, it is very natural in nature for there to be like non-parental ‘roles’ in like making sure there's a next generation of whatever.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: So, I'm like, you can't… it's just such an uninformed argument to be like, well, that's just natural, that's how biology is. Because like, first of all, it's not. And second of all, I think we could all agree humans are like a little more evolved than any other animal on the planet. It's like, why are we tying ourselves to that?
SARAH: And also, these are the same types of people who are saying that humans are greater than anything else. Like, we are a gift from God, God created us in his image, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. So, if we are better than the other creatures on the earth, because we're smarter and we're… we have more complex communities and we can build technology and shit, then shouldn't it follow that we have more complex reasons for being and existing?
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Yeah. But God said be fruitful and multiply.
KAYLA: But it's just like such a… it's such an unnuanced understanding…
SARAH: It always is.
KAYLA: Of that, because it's like… it's just like, why would you tie yourself to the understanding that like, in order for the human race to continue, we need every single person to pair off and have children? Like, why can there not be an understanding of like, to build a society where people can successfully evolve and create the next generation, some people, for that to work, are going to not have kids, cannot have kids because they need to be busy doing something else. Like, if you want to pair this down to like, a structural, like, let's make this a machine, let's make this a factory, some people need to have jobs other than reproduce to make sure that everything stays running while these people over here are the ones that have the kids.
SARAH: Well, and so much of the reason back in the olden days where it's like, you have to have a billion kids is because a thousand years ago, a lot of those kids died.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And so, like, half of them, maybe even more than half of them, would not grow to adulthood. They would not grow to be adults working in society and contributing to the community.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: That's no longer the case. Even in very poor places with maternal mortality rates and infant mortality rates that are not so great, there are still leaps and bounds better than it was a thousand years ago.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And are we not taking this into consideration? No, of course we're not.
KAYLA: No. And also, like, also the reason you needed a thousand kids was because you needed someone to work on the farm.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: And it's almost like when you create new technologies that replace people and then you're shocked that there are less people, it's like, well, you got rid of the reason to need this many people.
SARAH: If you like AI so much, because AI is going to take all of our jobs, why doesn't AI just, like, take over people, too? Like, what do we need to exist if AI is here?
KAYLA: But I'm… that's like literally what I'm saying, though
SARAH: I know
KAYLA: It is like, this is such a, like, nasty way of talking about this, but it's like, okay, if you're going to replace us, we physically don't need that many people anymore then.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Like, if the point of people, like, what they're talking about, it is like the point of people is to like be productive and grow more people.
SARAH: Mm-hmm
KAYLA: And it's like, okay, well, the productive thing to do anymore isn't to make new people because we don't need them. Like, if we're going to think about our country as a business and it's because of the economy that we need this many people to be here to function the country so it makes money like a business. But then we don't… we need to lay off some people, we need less employees in the country because you gave our jobs away.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: So, like, now you're mad that there's… but what am I going to do with these extra people?
SARAH: Also, humans are so fucking…
KAYLA: Because you didn't make jobs for them.
SARAH: Humans are so fucking resilient that, like, I… so I saw a video somewhat recently where it was, like, okay, what would happen if all of the women on the earth disappeared suddenly?
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And then what would happen if all of the men on the earth disappeared suddenly? And all of the women disappearing, the earth ends, essentially.
KAYLA: Great.
SARAH: Or not the earth, humanity, humanity ends.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: For the one where all the men disappear, that's half of the population gone.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: But with time, it would still be fine…
KAYLA: Because some of those women are pregnant with a boy.
SARAH: They're assuming that some of those women are pregnant with boys.
KAYLA: Hmm
SARAH: And so they were, like, you know, they were talking about how, you know, the jobs that women statistically don't do as much, like, they would learn how to do that and make sure that those needs are filled. And like they could come back from it, and I don't remember what the timeline was, but it was like well within a single lifetime.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Like, you could come back from that.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Humans are very resilient, we don't need six g-g-gillion of us.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Also, if they're using the… if they're going to use the appeal to God, like the whole be fruitful and multiply thing.
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: God also said a lot of other things.
KAYLA: It's true.
SARAH: And I think if you had like 500 children and you couldn't feed them…
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Or clothe them or shelter them, I think God might say, hey, maybe let's slow down on the fucking… you know?
KAYLA: I'm looking up the definition of ‘fruitful’ because I feel like we are only focusing on the multiply part.
SARAH: Yeah. Because fruitful is about flourishing. And if you have 500 kids who you can't feed, clothe, and shelter, that's not flourishing.
KAYLA: That's what I'm saying. Like, you can't just multiply.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: And then all your kids are shit. It's like, well, why did you do that?
SARAH: A lot of people interpret be fruitful as like get rich. And so, they only care about getting rich and…
KAYLA: Why would God care about that?
SARAH: Bro!
KAYLA: Why would God ever tell you to get rich?!
SARAH: Brother!
KAYLA: That seems like the opposite.
SARAH: It sounds like an MLM. Imagine an MLM where God is at the top. You know…
KAYLA: I mean, like, I don't know that Christianity is not an MLM.
SARAH: I was about to say, I think for some sects of Christianity, I think that's actually pretty real because it's like, you need to recruit people...
KAYLA: I mean, is Mormonism not an MLM?
SARAH: Next episode. Is Christianity a multi-level marketing scheme?
KAYLA: I mean, like, kind of, right?
SARAH: A little bit, yeah.
KAYLA: Like, they're sending people to your door to knock and recruit you and then, like, keeping track of your numbers, like…
SARAH: Yeah. I would say, well… I was going to say, certain sects believe that there are limited… I can't remember which ones, believe that there are limited numbers of spaces in heaven.
KAYLA: Wait, really?
SARAH: Yes, I don't remember which one.
KAYLA: That's funny.
SARAH: It's one of the more… like, extreme ones, obviously.
KAYLA: I have to assume so.
SARAH: But they believe that there is a limited number of slots in heaven, so…
KAYLA: So, they don't want to recruit.
SARAH: Yeah, like, they don't really want to recruit as much…
KAYLA: What?!
SARAH: Because they want to reserve those slots for themselves and their people.
KAYLA: That's wild.
SARAH: And I was like, well, I guess maybe that's less of an MLM, but I don't think that's true because the whole thing with an MLM is there is a limited pot of money, and if you get in early, you're more likely to get that money.
KAYLA: Yeah
SARAH: So, like, it's still all the same. Like, if you get in early, you're still more likely to get to heaven.
KAYLA: And you know what's stupid? It is that, because you're like, a lot of these religions are like, okay, you have to, like, be baptized or, like, follow God to get into heaven.
SARAH: Mm-hmm
KAYLA: Or else you're going to hell. But then also, if you're on your deathbed and you ask for a priest and you confess your sins and you ask to be baptized right there, they'll do it, and then you get to go to heaven. So really, you could just fast-pass it. Like, I could just be a piece of shit my whole life and then not follow religion at all, and then at my deathbed last minute be like, psych, I want to go to heaven. So, it's like, well, what are you teaching people?
SARAH: It's Jehovah's Witnesses.
KAYLA: Great.
SARAH: Jehovah's Witnesses believe that only 144,000 faithful individuals will go to heaven. That's not very many.
KAYLA: How specific? And like, why, though?
SARAH: Like, in the history of time too?
KAYLA: Is it small? Wait, in the history of ever? Well, it's certainly full by now, then, though.
SARAH: But Jehovah's Witnesses constantly be knocking on your door, they're still trying to recruit.
KAYLA: But if that's all time, then it has to be full by now.
SARAH: 12,000 from each of the 12 symbolic tribes of spiritual Israel.
KAYLA: What?! So, what if your tribe is full? Can you like switch tribes?
[00:30:00]
SARAH: Okay, the vast majority of faithful believers will not go to heaven because Jehovah's Witnesses recruit hard.
KAYLA: Well, then what's the point?
SARAH: Instead, they anticipate living forever on a restored physical paradise earth after Armageddon.
KAYLA: So, they should have to wait?
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Well, that's annoying.
SARAH: And like…
KAYLA: Wait, but how is there room enough for all these people on a restored earth post Armageddon, but heaven is... why is heaven the smaller place than a restored earth?
SARAH: Well, 144,000 anointed Christians will go to heaven and serve as kings and priests alongside Jesus Christ in a heavenly government.
KAYLA: Great!
SARAH: There's a government.
KAYLA: In heaven, there's a government, right. That doesn't sound like my heaven.
SARAH: If we're talking politics, that's got to be hell.
KAYLA: They should just do it like the Mormons where each person gets their own planet.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Alot roomier in that scenario.
SARAH: Yeah. Yeah, so Jehovah’s Witnesses, constantly recruiting and I guess...
KAYLA: Okay. Well, this is your sign not to join.
SARAH: You won't even go to heaven.
KAYLA: Slash, you're not even going to heaven. So, what the fuck is the point? You have to wait for the earth to end, which, hey, could be soon.
SARAH: Could be soon.
KAYLA: So maybe it's actually not that bad of a time to get in, I don't know.
SARAH: I saw it…
KAYLA: We've pissed off so many people just now.
SARAH: Yep. I saw an interview the other day with fucking Donald Trump.
KAYLA: Great.
SARAH: It was that fuck-ass guy that's on 60 Minutes now, now that Barry Weiss owns it.
KAYLA: Oh, he ruined 60 Minutes.
SARAH: And he was saying, I don't remember who he was talking about, but he was talking about another conservative figure who was asked, you know, there are a lot of people that you really don't like in politics, if you were on your deathbed, would you forgive them? Like, for an eternal life with Christ, would you forgive them?
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: And this person said, yes. And so, then the interviewer asks Donald Trump…
KAYLA: Oh no, oh no
SARAH: And he says, no.
KAYLA: Right. Sure.
SARAH: Because he's not actually… he doesn't actually believe…
KAYLA: No.
SARAH: In any of the Christianity shit he espouses.
KAYLA: No, no, no.
SARAH: He was like… he was basically… like he… I mean, he went on, he did the weave, you know?
KAYLA: Sure
SARAH: But he said no.
KAYLA: Right.
SARAH: I was like, okay, yeah, that checks out.
KAYLA: Sure. I mean, at least he's honest? I don't know. Like, I guess.
SARAH: No, that's literally what he said. He was like, well, but then wouldn't God know that I wasn't being truthful? Because I do hate them.
KAYLA: You know what? Got to hand it to him on that one. Like, yeah, he would. Sure.
SARAH: Listen, he's an insane person, but sometimes he has got bangers.
KAYLA: Listen, a broken clock and all that.
SARAH: Exactly. I also saw a video of him at the 2016 Primary Debates…
KAYLA: Oh no.
SARAH: And compared to now, he sounded so coherent.
KAYLA: Oh God
SARAH: Like, you don't even realize how much of a downhill is happening…
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Until you compare it. And I saw a tweet that was like, ‘he used to sound like this?!’
KAYLA: Oh my God, that makes me scared, I don't know if I can handle going back and watching that.
SARAH: I mean, it does make you feel a little bit better about the fact that he got elected, where it's like, he wasn't always like this. This is not what got him elected.
KAYLA: Yeah, that's fair.
SARAH: A lot of the same beliefs, but he puts a mustard on it, you know?
KAYLA: Yeah.
SARAH: Anyway, okay. Let's go back one more time. I would like to just briefly touch on ‘you have no sex organs; you're nothing.’
KAYLA: You’re nothing. So, you're nothing. Yeah, I mean, that's just fucked up because it's not as though trans people are the only people who don't have sex organs or are infertile.
SARAH: Yeah. Here's an idea…
KAYLA: So, like, what are you saying?
SARAH: Intersex people who have extra sex organs, they're everything.
KAYLA: They're everything, you're everything to me.
SARAH: Yeah, it's… the idea… also, to your point, so if a man, a good God-fearing Christian man is shooting off blanks…
KAYLA: Nothing.
SARAH: Does that mean he's nothing?
KAYLA: That's what confuses me too about like why it's so chill for men to get vasectomies.
SARAH: Mm-hmm
KAYLA: Like you never hear an outrage about that.
SARAH: No.
KAYLA: And it's like, is it not the same thing?
SARAH: But if women get their tubes tied, oh no, but what if in the future? What if? Oh…
KAYLA: But that… and it's like seen as like a sin and like, it's like this purity thing of like, why would a woman do that to her body? But like when a man does it, it's no one… Like I've never heard a moral outrage about vasectomies, ever.
SARAH: I guess maybe they can use the excuse that it is reversible. But…
KAYLA: I don't know. But it's not like it's an easy… like, it's… like, it is reversible? Yes. But it's not like it's just like, whatever. Like, it is a whole thing
SARAH: I mean, vasectomies from what I understand are quite easy to do.
KAYLA: I don't know.
SARAH: They're like outpatient, it takes 30 minutes.
KAYLA: I just feel as though there should be a moral panic around it.
SARAH: You heard it here first, kids, there should be a moral panic around vasectomies.
KAYLA: I just like, where are the Christians on this one?
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: Like I have never… like, do Christian men get vasectomies?
SARAH: I mean, I'm sure there are some very Far-Right people who believe that you shouldn't.
KAYLA: Well, because there are people who are like even birth control is a no-no.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: So, they must also be a no-vasectomy.
SARAH: Well, I think there's definitely a Venn diagram of people in the middle who say no birth control, but yes-vasectomies, that would not surprise me.
KAYLA: So fucking stupid, so stupid.
SARAH: Ugh
KAYLA: Yeah. I mean, it's just… like, the no sex organs, you're nothing. It's just like people just see people as like, if you aren't productive, then there's no point to you at all.
SARAH: Mm-hmm
KAYLA: There is someone in my life who, and this was years ago, so maybe they have had like a change of heart, but there was someone in my life I once heard that insinuated that once an old person retires, they should just die because they're not being productive in society anymore.
SARAH: Hmm, hmm
KAYLA: And it feels like that… like, a similar vibe of just like, well, if you're not contributing to society in this way, then like, what the fuck is the point of you? And it's like, well, what if I don't have to be productive for my life to be worth it?
SARAH: Okay, so, if a man is shooting off blanks, take him out back behind the bar and shoot him, I guess. Bar? I meant to say barn, but either is fine.
KAYLA: Anywhere, I guess. I mean, that is the insinuation of like, you have to do this for your life to be worth it.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: Which A, no, and B, again, economically, if we're talking about running a business here as our country, which they keep saying… like, that's what they keep trying to do, not everyone can be in the baby-making factory, some people have to run the hospitals.
SARAH: You know who famously didn't have kids?
KAYLA: No.
SARAH: Hitler.
KAYLA: That's actually kind of crazy when you think about it. I don't think I ever thought about that.
SARAH: Let me look up if...
KAYLA: He didn't even have blonde hair.
SARAH: No. Why didn't Hitler have kids? I don't know if that was a personal choice or if he was shooting off blanks. A combination of his personal ideology, public image strategy, and views on leadership. I see. So Nazi propaganda carefully cultivated an image of Hitler as a man entirely dedicated to Germany who had renounced all personal happiness and domestic life for his political mission. So, it's like a Catholic priest, like you're married to God, he was like, I'm married to Germany.
KAYLA: He’s married to Germany? Great. I mean, I guess, but also, if you're going to be touting like this is what the ideal family looks like, I feel like you should also have one.
SARAH: This line is giving, and I can't believe I'm about to say this, K-pop.
KAYLA: Oh?!
SARAH: He believed that marrying or settling down would cause him to lose his idealized appeal among female supporters.
KAYLA: Right.
SARAH: They had to think they had a chance.
KAYLA: Were people out there fan-girling over Hitler like that? Were we like sexualizing Hitler?
SARAH: I think in the early and mid-30s, definitely. When he was on the rise.
KAYLA: Hmm
SARAH: He was like a fucking JFK to those people.
KAYLA: He’s so ugly, at least JFK was hot.
SARAH: Didn't he have a wife when he died?
KAYLA: Yeah. Actually, I don't know that they were married, but there was a woman.
SARAH: There was a woman.
KAYLA: There was a woman. I kind of thought he did have a kid with that woman.
SARAH: Unverified rumors and tabloid claims have occasionally surfaced, no scientific…
KAYLA: Imagine your family secret is that your grandpa is like Hitler's kid.
SARAH: That's crazy. Because like obviously there are people who are related to him, still alive.
KAYLA: Sure
SARAH: But he doesn't have any direct descendants.
KAYLA: But imagine a secret direct descendant of Hitler.
SARAH: That'd be wild.
KAYLA: And your name? Donald J. Trump.
SARAH: Oh, he married Eva Braun one day before they died by suicide together.
KAYLA: That's nice. That's nice.
SARAH: So, there's that. He consciously rejected the idea of dynastic succession.
KAYLA: Huh!
SARAH: He expressed a belief that the children of great men rarely inherited their parents' exceptional abilities, viewing a direct heir as a potential political liability. Historians…
KAYLA: Well, now that doesn't make sense with his whole dogma, though. If you're saying you don't inherit your parents' greatness, then why are we still worried about genetics?
SARAH: Worried about the Aryan race
KAYLA: What?! Now, hold on!
SARAH: I think he doesn't consider that greatness, he considers that to be like the baseline.
KAYLA: Yeah, but I just feel like we're really…
[00:40:00]
SARAH: The whole Aryan race thing isn't real anyway, Aryan people are from like Iran, like historically.
KAYLA: I guess, I just really feel like he's messing with his whole schtick, though.
SARAH: Historians note that Hitler preferred relationships where he maintained total dominance…
KAYLA: Oh!
SARAH: And reportedly avoided deep romantic attachments or intimacy to remain singularly focused on his political and military goals. Do you think Hitler was fucking? This podcast has taken a turn.
KAYLA: I think he was a never-nude.
SARAH: A never-nude, really?
KAYLA: I think he… yeah. I think he was no-nut-November all year long.
SARAH: You know what I think?
KAYLA: Like in a like, I'm keeping my body pure, you know? Like those guys who are like, I never know the touch of a woman because I can't be distracted from my gains, I think that was his vibe.
SARAH: I think he definitely had people sucking his dick, but he was like, we can't do more than that.
KAYLA: You know, I think that actually makes sense because he's like, I can't risk having a child.
SARAH: Uh-huh. And of course he would never reciprocate.
KAYLA: Well, fuck no. Yeah, I bet he had someone on his staff that was like the dick-sucker.
SARAH: The dick-sucker.
KAYLA: But like purely in a business transaction of like I need to get rid of this urge because it's distracting me from my stupid work. So, like come in here and fix this so I can get back to my terrible, awful things I'm doing.
SARAH: Oh my God. Oh, Hitler's sister Paula did not have children. So, the last member of the family still bearing the Hitler surname on their tombstone was in 1960.
KAYLA: Well, so who was related to him then? Like descendants of cousins?
SARAH: In 2025, it was reported that only five members of the Hitler family bloodline, all men who fathered no children, were still living.
KAYLA: But how were they related to him?
SARAH: This figure does not include Hitler's maternal cousins, the Koppensteiners. Three of these descendants are sons of Adolf Hitler's nephew, William. William Hitler was not on good terms with Adolf, who referred to William as his loathsome nephew. He was publicly critical of his uncle, and he fought with the U.S. Navy during World War II.
KAYLA: Oh, that’s nice
SARAH: Imagine being in the U.S. Navy in World War II and your name is Hitler.
KAYLA: And your last name is Hitler? Yeah, no, no.
SARAH: After the war ended, he changed his name to Stuart Houston.
KAYLA: I should think so.
SARAH: And none of his sons, who all bear the last name Stuart Houston, have children of their own. So, it seems like they just kind of killed themselves off. They said, this bloodline…
KAYLA: And you know… and I think that's… and I think I too would make that decision.
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: I still think he has a secret child out there somewhere.
SARAH: Oh, here's another reason, his father, there aren't a lot of Hitlers because his father made up the last name.
KAYLA: What?!
SARAH: His father was born Alois Schicklgrüber, and he changed his surname on January 7th, 1877 to Hitler, derived from that of his deceased stepfather, Johann Georg Hiedler.
KAYLA: What the fuck is wrong with these people?!
SARAH: So, his dad made up the name Hitler. His family used many variations of the family surname Hitler almost interchangeably, the common variants included Hiedler, Hütle, and Hittler, with two T's.
KAYLA: People used to just be… you could just name yourself anything.
SARAH: Hiedler is funny. It's…
KAYLA: What was the original last name?
SARAH: Hiedler. It's H-I-E…
KAYLA: No, no, the one that his dad changed from.
SARAH: Schicklgrüber.
KAYLA: Can you imagine if that had just been kept?
SARAH: The most evil man…
KAYLA: The most evil man in history, we’re like, ugh, Schicklgrüber
SARAH: Oh, Schicklgrüber.
KAYLA: Can you imagine?
SARAH: What does that mean? Schickl… Schicklgrüber. Come on now. Schicklgrüber. Oh my god, his dad was born out of wedlock. Schicklgrüber was Hitler's grandmother's last name.
KAYLA: Oh my goodness
SARAH: His dad took his grandmother's last name, and then changed it to his stepdad's last name, but different.
KAYLA: Girl! Okay...
SARAH: Also, it's possible that Adolf's mother, Klara, may have been his dad's first cousin once removed, or his half-niece.
KAYLA: Great, right, and why not?
SARAH: Anyway. We've taken such a turn.
KAYLA: Yeah, classic, some classic stuff.
SARAH: We went from talking about how transphobes rely upon fertility things, transphobes using fertility concerns to back up their argument against transpeople, and somehow that became a deep dive into Adolf Hitler's family history.
KAYLA: I mean, I actually think it makes a lot of sense, because we started out with fascism.
SARAH: It does.
KAYLA: So, I think it actually makes lots of sense.
SARAH: What does Schickl…
KAYLA: Yeah, I simultaneously think… I don't think Hitler was like asexual or anything, I'm not claiming him.
SARAH: No, I don't want to claim that bitch.
KAYLA: I'm not claiming him. I do simultaneously think that he thought sex was impractical, but that also he fathered many secret children.
SARAH: He was just really obsessed with his shit, and not in a cute way.
KAYLA: But like… And in a way that… also, it doesn’t make sense, what do you mean you can't inherit your parents' talents? Then why are you so worried about genetics and inheriting things?
SARAH: Yeah.
KAYLA: It can't be both. What do you mean?
SARAH: I think a lot of his posturing about the Aryan race and like the good people and what they should be, probably comes from a place of deep insecurity about his own origins.
KAYLA: Yeah, because he doesn't look anything like that.
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: Was that part of what made him like relatable? It is like, oh, like, he also isn't perfect and doesn't think he's perfect?
SARAH: I think he thinks he's perfect, but I don't know.
KAYLA: I don't know, I'm not trying to get into a Nazi-German mind, I don't know why I'm trying to understand why they followed him, I don't know.
SARAH: Okay, the surname Schicklgrüber is a traditional southern German and Austrian compound name that means ‘little schick from the hollow’
KAYLA: Little shit
SARAH: Or one who digs near a pit or mine coming from schickl, a diminutive form of a personal name or related to arrangement slash fence posts and gruba, someone living near a pit, ditch, or hollow.
KAYLA: See, and this is what I'm saying, it is that we used to have people whose… it was so much their dedicated job to dig near an existing pit that it became their last name. We don't have jobs like that anymore.
SARAH: Exactly.
KAYLA: This is what I'm saying, we made machines for that.
SARAH: We need to dig near pits.
KAYLA: But this is what I'm saying, like, we keep getting rid of the jobs for the people, so, we just don’t need as many people
SARAH: Bring back the pits! The children yearn for the pits.
KAYLA: It just doesn't… economically, it's not making… it's not lining up.
SARAH: Yearning for the pits is also definitely a kink.
KAYLA: Yes.
SARAH: Kayla, what's our poll for this week?
KAYLA: I don't know. Was Hitler a never-nude?
SARAH: You know, if you don't know what a never-nude is, look it up.
KAYLA: It's in the name, I think it's pretty self-explanatory.
SARAH: It's from the television program, Arrested Development.
KAYLA: I don't think I knew that.
SARAH: Yeah, the ‘I blew myself,’ what's his face? He's a never-nude.
KAYLA: I mean, I know he was, I don’t know that that's where that like came from though.
SARAH: I assume that's where that came from, maybe that's...
KAYLA: A quick Google?
SARAH: Never-nude origin, yeah, it's from Arrested Development.
KAYLA: That's wild. Um, poll... I don't know.
SARAH: Are intersex people everything? Yes or yes?
KAYLA: Oh. Yes or yes?
SARAH: Great. Kayla, what’s your beef and your juice for this week?
KAYLA: Um, my beef is that I had to work until like 10 p.m. last night.
SARAH: Work, work, work…
KAYLA: Oh yeah, good, a good song. I had to work till like 10 p.m. yesterday.
SARAH: Why?
KAYLA: Because we had this big like competition that happens every year and it is at night
SARAH: The Olympics?
KAYLA: Kind of, yeah.
SARAH: No, that's every four years.
KAYLA: Yeah, it has been going… this competition has been going on for like hundreds of years, it's wild.
SARAH: Like the Olympics.
KAYLA: Just like the Olympics, yeah. So, I had to do that. So, then I was really sleepy-tired, but I was really worried that I was going to… people were going to scream in my face when I was dealing with the event and no one did.
SARAH: That's great.
KAYLA: So that was nice.
SARAH: I love that for you.
KAYLA: It was a real concern there for a while, ha ha ha.
SARAH: Hmm
KAYLA: My juice is today I went to Salem because I didn't have work…
SARAH: Hmm, spooky
KAYLA: And I got a photo of my aura taken.
SARAH: Ooh
KAYLA: And I had… a bunch of people's pictures, it was like one main color, but mine was all rainbow, and they were like, that's so rare. And I was like, thank you.
SARAH: Ooh, gay!
KAYLA: And my other juice is I got my planner for 2027 and I'm excited for it.
SARAH: Yay!
KAYLA: I'm going to be a Hobonichi girl for 2027.
SARAH: Ooh, she's going to plan so hard. My juice is… Addy's beef is that I had to take her to the vet, just to get her a checkup so that they would give me her flea and tick medication renewal.
KAYLA: Mm-hmm
SARAH: My juice is that the vet said that she was perfect; very beautiful and very perfect and she had such good teefies.
[00:50:00]
KAYLA: But was she… well, is part of that perfection her behavior at the vet? Because I can't imagine that's true.
SARAH: No. She only hissed once.
KAYLA: Hmm!
SARAH: And she was like looking at her teeth, the vet was, and she was like, aww, look at these beautiful teeth, perfect for biting me with.
KAYLA: You're like, uh-huh, and she will.
SARAH: Well, because they have a caution flag on her file at the vet.
KAYLA: Hmm, hmm…
SARAH: So, the vet came in and she was like, ooh, I don't really want to get bit at 9 a.m. on a Tuesday.
KAYLA: Caution; bites.
SARAH: She's just a little spicy, but she's very good and perfect.
KAYLA: She's just orange.
SARAH: And she's almost 10 pounds now, but the vet said that that is not a problem and that is a good weight for her.
KAYLA: Wow!
SARAH: My beef is when will AO3 return from war? I can't believe we didn't talk about this last week.
KAYLA: That is wild, actually.
SARAH: Archive of Our Own, beloved fan fiction website is down. They said two to four weeks because someone attacked it and they have to fix it. And usually when it's down, it's down for like maybe 12 hours max. It has been almost two weeks now…
KAYLA: Yeah, it has been a while.
SARAH: And they said two to four, I'm hoping for two. But a lot of people have been dealing illicit epub downloads and then there has been...
KAYLA: Do you think that's part of why the Blue tsunami happened? Because people had to get out of the house because AO3 was down?
SARAH: That's what people were saying, that's what people were saying. But also, there has been this horrible discourse of entitled fucking fanfic authors who think it's wrong to read downloaded fics because they're not getting their kudos and they're not getting their comments.
KAYLA: It's not like you're making money off of it.
SARAH: I know. And this insane person made like a list… they were like, we should unionize and make... And we're like, unionize against who?
KAYLA: Do you know what a union is? What the fuck are you saying?
SARAH: And they were like, we should be able to have… put a chapter up and then you can't see the next chapter unless you leave a comment, but that comment has to be approved by the author.
KAYLA: What?!
SARAH: And I'm like, that is a great way to make sure no one reads your next fucking chapter.
KAYLA: But also, like, that's just a paywall without the pay. So, like literally what's the point?
SARAH: Right. And it's not just like, oh, I read chapter one, let me leave a comment. Like, it has to be approved. So, if the author doesn't approve it for 24 hours, you can't go on to the next chapter.
KAYLA: This is all just because they want like the most likes? Like, what is the point?
SARAH: I don't know. And they were also like, we want to wait so that like fanfic writers can make money. And it's like, that is directly against the Terms of Service of Archive of Our Own.
KAYLA: Like, that's just never going to... unless you...
SARAH: That is fundamentally against AO3’s terms
KAYLA: You would have to go off-site and create a new...
SARAH: Yeah
KAYLA: Like, you have to create a whole new thing. And also, then you're going to get sued, probably.
SARAH: Yeah. And then people were like... because people were like compiling Google Drive links of like, here are a bunch of fics that I've downloaded with this ship and this fandom and whatever. And then the entitled bitches who write fanfiction for attention, and comments? I guess?
KAYLA: I guess, yeah
SARAH: Were being bitches and people were like... I mean, in compiling all this stuff, it's almost as if we're building an archive of our own.
KAYLA: An archive of our own, hmm
SARAH: Interesting.
KAYLA: So wild.
SARAH: Anyway, I hope AO3 returns from war. I've been reading some epubs, but you can't search the same way, you're just at the mercy of what people have downloaded.
KAYLA: Hmm
SARAH: You can tell us about your beef, your juice, your sadness about AO3 being down. Also, can like the general public stop putting AO3 readers on blast? Being like, guys, this website is down. If they know, they know, it doesn't need to be on CNN. Okay.
KAYLA: I did not know CNN was covering that!
SARAH: We get our like book scouting report from our book scouts and in one of them this week, they were like, hey, the popular fanfiction website, Archive of Our Own is down, whatever, whatever. And my coworker texted me and was like, why are we being exposed like this?
KAYLA: Triggered at work.
SARAH: And I was like, they should have said AO3 is down, if you don't know what that means, don't look it up. If you do, you get it. Like…
KAYLA: It doesn’t matter, sorry.
SARAH: Anyway, you can tell us about your beef, your juice on our social media @soundsfakepod. We also have a Patreon, patreon.com/soundsfakepod. Our $5 patrons who we are promoting this week are Alucard Zavertnik, Amanda Kyker, Clark Fadoir, Jiro the Wolf and Arctic Enby. Our $10 patrons who are promoting something this week are Benjamin Ybarra, who would like to promote Tabletop games. Clare Olsen, who would like promote @Impact_Frames. Impact_Frame; singular, but they do make multiple. Danielle Hutchinson, who would like to promote Rainbow Pride Knits. Derick & Carissa, who would like to promote supporting each other through the transitions we face. And Elle Bitter, who would like to promote normalizing the use of tone indicators /srs. Oh, wait, I can't be doing that, nope, Dick's on cheese. Okay. What? Oh, wait, no, Dick's on cheese. On cheese, on cheese, okay. Our other $10 patrons are Eric, Johanna, Kayla's dad, Maff, Martin Chiesl, Purple Hayes, Quartertone, Barefoot Backpacker, SongOStorm, Alastor, Ani, and Arcnes? I may have said Arcnes twice. Our… our… where are we? Our $15 patrons are Kayla's aunt Nina, who would like to promote katemaggartart.com. And Schnell, who would like to promote accepting that everyone is different and that's awesome. Our $20 patrons are Dr. Jacki Willenborg, we're getting German today, and River, and they would like to promote, do you think maybe if his dad had kept the last name Schicklgruber, if Hitler would have become a different man?
KAYLA: Yeah, probably.
SARAH: Do you think, actually, if he had gotten into art school, things would be vastly different in our world today?
KAYLA: Yes.
SARAH: I probably think so too. Thanks for listening, tune in next Sunday for more of us in your ears. Whether you like it or not!
KAYLA: And until then, take good care of your cows.
[END OF TRANSCRIPT]